Stockmarket Update 23 May 2010
Stock market update as of the week ending Friday, 21 May 2010.
Another week of selling in all the major markets. This week produced some interesting technical changes that need to be discussed.
Click on all charts to enlarge:
Major Market Indexes (weekly):
The first chart is a simple weekly line chart of the major market indexes (INDU = Down Jones Industrial Average, SPX = S&P 500 Index, COMPQ = Nasdaq Composite Index, RUT = Russell 2000 Index, DJW = Dow Jones World Index, NDX = Nasdaq 100 Index).
In all cases it can be seen that the uptrend line from the March, 2009 bottom has been broken to the downside. However, with the exception of the Dow Jones World Index, all the other "U.S. oriented" indexes remain above their last significant lows (shown by a red line on each chart).
The fact the Dow Jones World Index closed below it's last significant low is indicative of the fact this decline is being led by China and Europe (as discussed in a previous blog).
Trend line analysis appears to be simple in theory but there is actually quite an art to it. Technicians use differing "rules" on when a trend line break is significant.
The rules I use when confirming a break of an up trend line has truly indicated a major market reversal is price must confirm by closing BELOW the last area of significant support anchoring the relevant trend line. This has not occurred (as of yet) on the majority of the indexes (other than the D.J. World Index) so we are in the "in between" area between the last up trend and the previous area of support. This is shown as the beige zone on the chart.
I classify the current overall market trend as being NEUTRAL.
Dow Jones Primary Sell Theory
Having said the above, a bearish sell signal was generated on Thursday based upon an indicator known as the Dow Primary Trend Theory Indicator.
The Dow Jones Primary Trend Theory is one of the oldest forms of Technical Analysis. Unto itself it means little day-to-day but it must be noted this theory is followed by MANY money managers so it needs to be watched closely.
Basically, the theory is that signals on the D.J. Industrial Index must match signals on the D.J. Transport Index. This is because the "industrial products" manufactured must be "transported" to customers. If both the industrials and transports are on buy signals then you have a primary bullish trend. When both are on sell signals you have a bearish trend. When they are in disagreement you have a neutral "undecided" signal.
Dow Theory Sell Signal:
On Thursday both the Industrials and the Transports broke below their last significant area of support (set in early May and shown with the red line). This confirmed a Dow Theory primary sell signal.
This is not a tradable signal but it changes the overall view of the markets in a much more bearish direction.
SPX 11 year monthly:
The long term monthly chart remains bullish. The final decision on this chart is based on monthly closing price ONLY (it can dip below mid-month).
The long term chart remains BULLISH.
SPX 3 year weekly:
The weekly chart has turned bearish with the technical indicators confirming. This indicates we MAY be into the early stages of new bear market or we MAY be in a correction mode before the next market advance.
I have drawn a key level of support on the chart from Feb, 2010. If the daily closing low of 1044.50 were to be violated I would get worried; if the weekly closing low of 1066.19 were to be violated I would become VERY CONCERNED and bearish. We are not there yet.
The intermediate term weekly chart is NEUTRAL-BEARISH.
SPX daily from 2009 bottom:
This is a new chart I have not shown before. It is a simplistic view of the current market advance off the March, 2009 bottom.
As can be seen (and discussed previous), we are in a "neutral zone" below the rising trend line and the last area of significant support.
I have drawn 2 possible dotted blue trend lines; a bullish rising one and a bearish falling one. If price were to take out 1044.50 on a closing daily basis the current market rally would be over and I would change the descending dotted trend line to solid. It would be controlling and we would be in a new down trending market.
If price were to close above 1173.57 on on a closing daily basis the current market rally would be still intact and I would change the ascending dotted trend line to solid. It would be controlling and we would be in the next phase of a new up trending market.
Anything in between is neutral as it is nothing more than market noise that could go either way. We are currently in this position.
SPX daily with volumetric:
The daily chart with volumetric shows the continued strong support and resistance zone between 1040-1130. Interesting to note price on Thursday closed below the fairly strong volumetric support line @ 1080 (the middle black line) yet popped back into that area on Friday. This is encouraging.
It is possible the market has transitioned into a new more shallow price channel than previous. I have indicated this channel in a red dotted fashion and it is also interesting to note Thursdays low bounce right off the possible lower support channel.
SPX Point and Figure Traditional:
A very negative development that occurred last week is the Point and Figure chart turned bearish. It is now targeting a price of 940.
SPX 6 month daily:
Another bearish development is on Thursday price broke below the 200 day moving average (shown in green). During the early stages of a bear market once this occurs price may recover but many times finds resistance at the 50 day moving average while longer term turning lower.
The only positive thing to note on the chart is price did not close below the Feb 08 closing low of 1056.51. This combined with the oversold nature of the market has me expecting a bounce upwards as early as Monday.
The short term charts remain BEARISH.
Bottom Line:
As you can probably discern by my comments, technically the markets are at a "wishy-washy" point where they could go either way. There are some charts that are bearish; some that are bullish. Sometimes things are crystal clear; sometimes they are hazy. That is the nature of investment and that is where we stand today.
In my experience, the best investment decisions I have made are those where I sit on my hands during times of indecision and let the market tell me where it wants to go. When the time is right I have no problem becoming bearish and committing to cash (or more likely shorting the market) and there are times when patience is a virtue and you stay long and bullish in the face of danger. That is where I feel we are at today.
I remain long term bullish and intermediate term neutral on the markets. There is nothing in the longer term charts that indicate we have begun a new bear market decline. As such, until they do so I remain in cautious "Bull" mode and view the current decline as a correction of the overbought nature of the markets over the past few months.
It is not to say that we may have just experienced the....... "this time it's different" scenario that could possibly have moved the market from a bull market to a bear market basically overnight. It is only with time/price action that this would become apparent but the odds do not favor such a scenario. What I can say is my long term indicators have an excellent record of being right and, as of yet, they have not indicated the bull market advance from the March, 2009 bottom is over.
My "gut" feeling is we have entered a consolidation period in the markets to digest the huge rise off the March, 2009 bottom. Seasonally markets tend to be weak going into the summer (the" sell in May and go away" scenario) followed by a summer rally followed by a further decline into the fall. I still believe whatever low we set into this fall will be a great time to go "all-in" based upon the Presidential 4 year stock market cycle (also discussed in a previous blog).
I am neither a bull nor a bear. I go wherever I can make money and I never, never let emotion creep into my investment decisions. Hard to do sometimes but over the years I have learned this is what needs to be done.
We are in a neutral zone where this can go either way. I lean cautiously bullish and am positioned accordingly in the Provident Fund (still holding 25% cash).
Ironically the ECAM Asset Allocation Fund, which is 100% technically driven (and can be thought of as 10 independent "brains" all thinking individually based upon their "specific area of expertise"), is positioned neutral as well (45% invested/55% cash) based upon their very strict, totally technically driven indicators I employ to each asset class.
Emirates Provident Fund:
As of today my "strategic positioning" within the Emirates Provident Fund A and B accounts remains at a 75% Equity/25% USD cash position. (1) see below
I have received numerous emails the past few weeks from those subscribers who want more specific details as to exactly which equity fund(s) I hold within the Provident Fund account.
The short answer is.....it doesn't matter.
The funds available within the Emirates Provident Fund A/B accounts (BlackRock/MLIM Equity Portfolio vs. Fidelity International Fund vs. Russell Global 90 Fund) will move +/- a percent or two year-to-year. In the end you could flip a coin and have as good a chance of picking the outperforming EK equity fund as I could.
The key is that none of these funds will EVER provide for a long term secure retirement given their extremely limited exposure to the investment universe and their mandates to be "relative performance" funds (ie, not actively managed). I only deal with them because the company tells me I must. Given my choice I would have 0% in the EK accounts.
I will do a more in-depth discussion on this at a future date but since there appears to be a desire to have specific direction on what I do:
1) 100% of my REQUIRED monthly provident fund investment purchases (the A + B account purchases the company requires me to contribute) goes 100% into equities. It has for the past 11 years and I NEVER CHANGE THIS ALLOCATION NO MATTER WHAT DIRECTION THE EQUITY MARKETS TAKE.
2) Of those ongoing required monthly purchases, the monthly allocation I have assigned is as follows:
-Russell Global 90 Fund-40%
-BlackRock/MLIM Equity Portfolio-30%
-Fidelity International Fund-30%
3) My current holdings (based upon technical market timing) are approximately as follows (market fluctuations change the mix somewhat):
-BlackRock/MLIM Equity Portfolio-50%
-Russell Global 90 Fund-15%
-Fidelity International Fund-10%
-BlackRock/MLIM US Dollar Cash Portfolio-25%
The reason I have such a high exposure to BlackRock/MLIM Equity is not because I feel they can outperform the others; it is only because they give me the "out" to move to USD cash more quickly in the event of a market crash (as discussed in a previous blog below):
http://emiratescapitalassetmanagement.blogspot.com/2010/04/provident-fund-switching-anomaly.html).
3) All other investments (ie. my entire free monthly investment cash flow other than that described above) I put into the ECAM Asset Allocation Fund.
I have not seen a more effective method of long term investment to date and there is no other investment strategy I would commit my retirement savings to.
Emirates Capital Asset Management (ECAM) Asset Allocation Fund:
The ECAM Asset Allocation Fund (my personal C account) remains at a 45% invested/55% cash position. (2) see below
Current holdings:
Core Strategic Asset Holdings (90% of entire assets under management):
-U.S. Large cap equities:10% (VTI)
-U.S. Small cap equities: 5% (VB)
-U.S. Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs): 10% (VNQ)
-U.S. Domestic bonds: 10% (BND)
-U.S. Inflation protected bonds: 5% (TIP)
-Cash: 50%
Discretionary (10% of entire assets under management):
-Gold mining stocks: 5% (GDX)
-Cash: 5%
Legal Disclaimer: The content on this site is provided without any warranty, express or implied. All opinions expressed on this site are those of the author and may contain errors or omissions. NO MATERIAL HERE CONSTITUTES "INVESTMENT ADVICE" NOR IS IT A RECOMMENDATION TO BUY OR SELL ANY FINANCIAL INSTRUMENT, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO STOCKS, OPTIONS, BONDS OR FUTURES. The author will reveal his current market positions and holdings but actions you undertake as a consequence of any analysis, opinion or advertisement on this site are your sole responsibility. The author is not licensed as an investment advisor in the UAE and therefore cannot provide individual account advice to individuals and/or institutions.
dwaynemalone1@gmail.com
(1) Emirates Provident Fund "Strategic positioning" percentages are as per how funds were originally allotted. Due to daily market price fluctuations and ongoing equity monthly purchases within the Provident Fund account these amounts will vary several percent from that posted.
(2) The Emirates Capital Asset Allocation Fund is a composite investment fund based upon Modern Portfolio Theory and Strategic Asset Allocation.
It is composed of the following asset classes and percentage of potential exposure to each asset class:
Core Holdings (90%):
-U.S. Domestic Large Cap Equities-(10%)
-U.S. Domestic Small Cap Equities-(5%)
-Foreign Established Markets Equities-(10%)
-Emerging Market Equities-(15%)
-U.S. Domestic Bonds-(10%)
-U.S. Treasury Inflation Protected Bonds-(5%)
-U.S. Domestic Real Estate Trusts (REIT)-(10%)
-Foreign Real Estate Trusts-(5%)
-Hard Commodities-(10%)
-Soft Commodities-(5%)
-Managed timber-(5%)
Discretionary Asset Holds (10%):
-any asset class with shorter term positive technical indications that the manager deems appropriate for inclusion into the fund for the potential for added alpha returns.
Each asset class within the fund is individually invested based upon strict technical analysis criteria. Asset classes without a positive technical outlook are moved into cash. When the majority of equity asset classes are deemed in bear markets up to 50% of the equity positon may be positioned in short market/put option instruments.